The distinction between narcissism and egoism is one of the most fertile and, at the same time, complex themes in psychoanalytic theory. Although in common parlance the terms are used almost as synonyms to describe someone "self-centered," for psychoanalysis, especially following the fundamental contributions of Sigmund Freud, they occupy distinct theoretical positions, even though they share a common root in the libidinal economy.
The Genesis of Narcissism in Freudian Theory
In psychoanalysis, narcissism is not viewed as a character flaw, but as a necessary stage of human development. In his seminal 1914 essay, "On Narcissism: An Introduction," Freud postulates that we all pass through an original state called primary narcissism.
Primary Narcissism
In this phase, the infant does not differentiate the "I" (Ego) from the "External World." All of their psychic energy (libido) is invested in themselves. They are, to themselves, the center of the universe, what Freud affectionately called "His Majesty the Baby." There are no external objects of desire yet; the ego is in the process of formation and takes itself as its own object.
Secondary Narcissism
As the child grows, they realize they cannot satisfy all their needs alone. They begin to invest their libido in external objects (usually caregivers). Secondary narcissism occurs when this libido, which had been sent out into the external world, suffers a frustration or trauma and withdraws back into the Ego. It is a movement of reflux: the energy that should be attached to people or projects returns to the subject in a defensive or pathological way.
Defining Egoism through a Psychoanalytic Lens
Egoism, on the other hand, is a concept focused more on self-preservation and the individual's practical interests. While narcissism concerns where the "passion" (libido) is invested, egoism concerns utility and self-benefit.
Freud differentiated the Ego-Drives (or self-preservation drives) from the Sexual Drives (libidinal). Egoism is linked to the conservation of biological and social life. An egoistic individual is one who seeks their own advantage, often at the expense of others, but this does not necessarily mean they have a morbid "passion" for their own image.
- Practical Example: A businessman who evades taxes to increase profit is acting egoistically (focus on material benefit). Conversely, an individual who constantly needs to be admired and cannot tolerate criticism because their self-image is fragile is manifesting a narcissistic trait (focus on the libidinal investment of the Self).
Structural Differences: Libido vs. Interest
"Healthy" Egoism
For psychoanalysis, a certain degree of egoism is vital. Without it, the individual would not care for their health, finances, or physical integrity. It is the "survival instinct" translated into social behavior.
Narcissism and Fragility
The narcissist is not necessarily someone who "loves themselves too much." On the contrary, in clinical psychoanalysis, exacerbated narcissism often hides a fragile Ego. The individual invests massively in their own image because, deep down, they fear their "Self" will disintegrate. They depend on the external gaze to confirm their existence, becoming a slave to the admiration of others.
The Object and Alterity
One of the deepest differences lies in how the "Other" (alterity) is perceived in each case.
- In egoism, the other is recognized as a separate subject. The egoist knows you exist and have desires, but they choose to ignore them in favor of their own. There is a clear separation between "I" and "you."
- In pathological narcissism, the boundary is blurred. The other is not seen as an independent person, but as a "self-object." The narcissist uses people as extensions of themselves. If the other fails to mirror the narcissist's perfection, they are discarded or attacked, as their independence is felt as an aggression against the integrity of the narcissistic ego.
Narcissism and Identification: The Ego Ideal
To understand why narcissism is so central to psychoanalysis, we must speak of the Ego Ideal. This is the standard of perfection that the subject strives to achieve to recover the satisfaction of primary narcissism (when they believed themselves to be perfect).
The narcissist lives for this Ideal. They do not just seek "things" (like the egoist); they seek to be the incarnation of that ideal. This generates a profound suffering known as a Narcissistic Injury. When the real world shows the narcissist they are fallible, the pain is not just about "losing an advantage" (as it would be for the egoist), but an existential pain of annihilation.
Convergence and Divergence in Daily Life
- Is it possible to be egoistic without being narcissistic? Yes. An individual can be extremely focused on material gains (egoism) but have a realistic self-image and not require constant praise (low narcissism).
- Is it possible to be narcissistic without being egoistic? It is rarer, but yes. There are "altruistic narcissists", people who dedicate their lives to helping others, not out of real empathy, but to be seen as "saints," "heroic," or "the best people in the world." Here, the investment is in the image of benevolence, even though the external behavior seems the opposite of traditional egoism.
Clinical Implications: The Treatment
In the psychoanalytic clinic, treating egoism is a matter of ethics and the development of empathy. However, the treatment of narcissistic neuroses is much more challenging.
The narcissist has difficulty establishing transference (the bond with the analyst) because they cannot invest libido in the analyst; they are too busy investing it in themselves. Therapeutic progress involves helping the patient "withdraw" some of this energy from the Self and accept that the external world and other people have intrinsic value, regardless of their utility.
Conclusion
Thus, while egoism is a mode of action geared toward having and gaining, narcissism is a mode of being geared toward appearing and feeling. The egoist wants the best for themselves; the narcissist wants to be the best.
Freud's distinction teaches us that psychic health resides in balance: we need functional egoism to survive and healthy narcissism for self-esteem and dignity. The problem arises when narcissism becomes a wall that prevents the recognition of the other, turning the world into a vast hall of mirrors where the subject, lost in their own image, becomes incapable of loving. As Freud himself stated: "We must begin to love in order not to fall ill." Love (libidinal investment in the other) is the only real cure for narcissistic imprisonment.
0 Comments:
Postar um comentário