The concept of the phallus is, without a doubt, one of the most complex, debated, and often misunderstood pillars of psychoanalytic theory. To understand what Freud and, later, Lacan meant by this term, one must first strip away the idea that the phallus is simply a biological synonym for the penis, since the phallus, for psychoanalysis, is not an organ but a symbolic operator. It represents presence, potency, desire, and, above all, the law that organizes culture and the human psyche.
Freud’s Origin: The Primacy of the Phallus
Sigmund Freud introduced the importance of the “phallic phase” in psychosexual development (around ages 3 to 5). For Freud, at this stage, the child, regardless of biological sex, recognizes only one genital organ as significant: the penis.
Anatomical Difference and Castration
During this period, the child believes that everyone has a penis. The discovery of anatomical difference between the sexes is experienced as a trauma.
The boy: Fears losing what he has (castration anxiety).
The girl: Feels she has been deprived of something (penis envy).
It is essential to note that, for Freud, the phallus functions as a symbolic currency. It is the object that separates “having” from “not having.” The child attributes to the phallus the source of all pleasure and power, and the threat of its loss (castration) is what forces entry into the Oedipus Complex and the acceptance of social laws.
Lacan’s Revolution: The Phallus as Signifier
If Freud laid the biological and imaginary foundations, it was Jacques Lacan who elevated the phallus to the category of Signifier. For Lacan, the phallus is neither a real object (the penis) nor a fantasy (an imaginary object), but the “Signifier of Desire.”
The Phallus as Lack
Lacan argues that the phallus symbolizes something that no one truly possesses. The moment we enter language, we lose our direct connection to nature and to full satisfaction. The phallus comes to represent this constitutive lack.
To explain this, Lacan divides the relation to the phallus into two dimensions:
To Be the Phallus (être le phallus): Early in life, the child wishes to be what completes the mother. If the mother desires something beyond the child, the child attempts to “be the phallus” for her, filling her void.
To Have the Phallus (avoir le phallus): With the intervention of the paternal function (the Name-of-the-Father), the child understands that no one is the phallus. The father appears as the one who supposedly has the phallus. Psychic maturity involves accepting that the phallus is something that circulates but never fully belongs to anyone.
The Symbolic Function and Desire
The phallus is what gives direction to human desire. Since we can never reach total satisfaction (“Jouissance”), desire is always displaced from one object to another. The phallus functions as the “north” of this compass.
The Paternal Metaphor
The transition from “being” to “having” occurs through the Paternal Metaphor. The Father (not necessarily the biological father, but the function that imposes limits) prohibits the mother’s desire for the child and vice versa. This interdiction creates the Law. The phallus then becomes the symbol of this Law: it states that total pleasure is forbidden, but desire may exist within the rules of culture.
Difference Between Penis and Phallus
This is the most important distinction to avoid sexist or purely biological interpretations of psychoanalysis:
| Attribute | Penis | Phallus |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Biological, anatomical organ | Signifier, symbol, function |
| Status | Real (can be seen/touched) | Symbolic (represents power/desire) |
| Gender | Belongs to the male body | Operates across men and women equally |
| Loss | Occurs only through physical trauma | “Castration” is symbolic and universal |
Understanding the phallus as a symbol allows us to see that a woman may occupy the position of “having the phallus” (through career, intellect, or social position) just as much as a man. Likewise, a man may feel “castrated” (without the phallus) regardless of his physical integrity.
The Phallus and Culture: Why This Term?
Many contemporary critiques question why psychoanalysis maintains a term so tied to male anatomy. The answer lies in the history of civilization.
The phallus has historically been the emblem of power, light, and the generation of life in various cultures (from Egyptian obelisks to Dionysian rituals). Psychoanalysis uses this term because it was already culturally charged before Freud. It represents the human aspiration toward totality.
Castration: The Phallus’s “Side B”
One cannot speak of the phallus without speaking of castration. In psychoanalysis, castration is not mutilation but the acceptance that we are limited beings.
Accepting castration means admitting that:
- We cannot have everything.
- We are not the center of the universe.
- Language will never fully express what we feel.
The phallus is what remains from this operation. It symbolizes that although we have lost original “completeness,” we have gained the capacity to desire, create art, form relationships, and build civilizations.
The Phallus in Psychoanalytic Clinic
In therapeutic practice, the analyst observes how the patient deals with their “phallic relation.”
Neurosis: The subject suffers because they desperately try to hide their castration, pretending to “have” the phallus at all times (ostentation, pursuit of infinite power).
Hysteria: The subject may question the other’s phallus (“What does he have that I don’t?”).
Perversion: The subject denies castration and attempts to create fetishes that substitute for the lost phallus.
The goal of analysis is to lead the subject to recognize that the phallus is merely a signifier, a “promise” of satisfaction that is never fully fulfilled, and that it is possible to live well with this lack.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the meaning of the phallus in psychoanalysis is that of a mediator. It is the bridge between the individual and culture. It is because of the phallus (and the lack it represents) that we seek the Other. If we were complete and lacked nothing, there would be no reason to speak, love, or work.
The phallus reminds us that we are beings of desire. It organizes our perception of value and allows us to navigate a world where not everything is possible, but where desire can find creative paths for expression.
0 Comments:
Postar um comentário