Psychoanalysis is not a method of mental analysis based on the idea of wholeness, but a rigorous investigation into what we lack. While common sense views "lack" as a void to be filled or a problem to be solved, for Freud and, fundamentally, for Jacques Lacan, lack is the gear that allows desire to exist. Without the hole in the net, the fish cannot swim; without the lack, the subject does not move.
The Origin of Desire in the Experience of Satisfaction
To understand lack, we must return to the beginning of psychic life. The human infant is born in a state of absolute biological helplessness (Hilflosigkeit). He depends entirely on an "Other" (usually the mother or whoever performs that function) to survive. When hunger strikes, an unbearable internal tension arises. The baby cries, and the Other intervenes, offering the breast or the bottle.
At this moment, what Freud called the Experience of Satisfaction occurs. However, something curious happens: satisfaction is never total. There is a "remainder" (reste) left over. The baby does not just want the milk (a biological need); he wants to recover the mythical sensation of totality he experienced in that encounter.
The problem is that the memory of this satisfaction is a construction. The subject spends his life trying to find an object that, in reality, never existed in the perfect form he imagines. This is where desire is born. Desire is not the search for a real object, but the search for an object lost forever. Lack, therefore, is the space between biological need (which can be satiated) and desire (which is insatiable). If there were no lack, if the mother were glued to the baby 24 hours a day, filling every gap of silence, the subject would not develop; he would be swallowed by the Other. Lack is what allows the baby to perceive that he and the mother are two distinct beings.
The Mirror Stage and the Lack in the I
If lack moves desire, it also grounds our identity. Jacques Lacan introduced the concept of the Mirror Stage to explain how we form our "I" (the Ego). Before this moment, the child perceives itself as a fragmented body, a jumble of disconnected sensations. Between 6 and 18 months, upon seeing its image in the mirror (or the reflection in the mother’s gaze), the child identifies with that totalized form.
The tragic irony of psychoanalysis is that this image of "perfection" and "unity" is a lie. The Ego is built upon an alienation: I see myself there where I am not. The image in the mirror is complete, but the subject who looks continues to feel the internal lack and fragmentation.
Lack, here, assumes the role of a rift (fente). We are never identical to the image we project to the world. There is always an abyss between who we think we are and what we actually feel. This constitutive lack is what makes us seek confirmation of our existence in the other. We seek partners, titles, and external validations to try to "glue" this crack in the mirror, but the lack remains there, silent, reminding us that completeness is merely an optical illusion.
Symbolic Castration and the Object Small a
One of the most misunderstood concepts in psychoanalysis is Castration. Far from being a physical threat, symbolic castration is the operation that introduces lack into culture and language. It is the "No" that separates the subject from his primordial object of desire.
For Lacan, castration is the moment when the subject accepts that he does not have everything and is not everything to the Other. It is a necessary sacrifice: we lose the illusion of omnipotence to gain the right to enter language and social life. He who does not undergo castration (in the symbolic sense) remains trapped in delusions of grandeur or absolute dependence, with no room to desire for himself.
From this cutting operation, a residue remains which Lacan called the Object small a (objet petit a).
- The object a is the cause of desire.
- It is not the object we desire (the car, the job, the person), but the luster those objects seem to have that attracts us.
- It is the void around which desire orbits.
Imagine a ring: the object a is not the precious metal, but the hole in the center. It is the hole that defines the ring. In life, we chase various "objects" trying to plug this hole, but as soon as we reach them, the satisfaction is short-lived. Desire soon displaces to something else. Lack is not a mistake along the way; it is the road itself.
Language as the Creator of Absences
"The word is the death of the thing." This classic psychoanalytic phrase summarizes how language introduces lack into our reality. When I say the word "apple," I do not have the fruit in my hand. The word arises precisely because the object is absent. If I had everything I wanted the moment I wanted it, I wouldn't need to speak.
We are "speaking beings" (parlêtres) because we lack something. The moment we enter the world of symbols, we are marked by an irremediable loss: the loss of direct, raw contact with the Real. Now, everything passes through the filter of words, which are always insufficient.
That feeling that "words cannot describe what I feel"? That is lack operating. There is something in the human being that escapes language, something that cannot be said. This unnamable "remainder" is what keeps us in analysis, trying to translate the untranslatable. Lack is the engine of creativity, art, and literature. The artist creates to try to give form to what is missing; he contours the void with brushstrokes, musical notes, or verses. If we were whole, silence would be absolute.
Lack as the Ethics of Desire
Finally, what is the practical use of understanding lack? In contemporary times, we live under the imperative of consumption, which sells us the promise that lack can be eliminated. "Buy this and feel complete," "Take this course and solve your life," "Find your soulmate and never suffer again." Advertising is the greatest enemy of lack, as it tries to transform it into a "deficiency" (carência) that can be filled.
Psychoanalysis proposes the opposite path. Mental health does not consist in eliminating lack, but in doing something with it.
- Assuming the lack is liberating: when I accept that no one can complete me, I stop demanding from my partner or my children something they cannot give.
- Differentiating Lack from Privation: Privation is not having something I could have (e.g., food, money). Lack is existential. I can be a billionaire and still be traversed by lack.
- Sustaining Desire: Mourning completeness allows the subject to stop searching for "The One Object" and start taking interest in the multiplicity of life.
Thus, lack is what makes us human. It is because we lack that we love, because in love, as Lacan said, "we offer what we do not have to someone who does not want it." We offer our own lack, our vulnerability, and it is in this encounter of two incomplete beings that something genuine can happen. The cure in psychoanalysis is not "becoming full," but learning to navigate the void without the panic of drowning in it.
0 Comments:
Postar um comentário